Tue 13 April, 2004 16:30
By Alan Elsner
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - The U.S. Justice Department under Attorney
General John Ashcroft failed in 2001 to treat counterterrorism as a
top priority, says the commission on the September 11 attacks.
The commission staff statement was issued before the start of two
days of hearings on the failure of the FBI and other agencies to
prevent the 2001 attacks on New York and Washington that killed
around 3,000 people.
It focused on a May 10 Justice Department document that set out
priorities for that year. The top priorities cited were reducing gun
violence and combating drug trafficking. It made no mention of
counterterrorism.
When Dale Watson, the head of the counterterrorism division, saw
the report, he "almost fell out of his chair," the report said.
"The FBI's new counterterrorism strategy was not a focus of the
Justice Department in 2001," it added.
Then-acting FBI Director Thomas Pickard said he appealed to
Ashcroft for more money for counterterrorism but on Sept 10, 2001,
one day before the hijacked airliner attacks, Ashcroft rejected the
appeal.
Former FBI Director Louis Freeh, testifying before the
commission, said the bureau's counterterrorism operations were
severely underfunded and understaffed in the years leading up to the
attacks.
"In the budget years 2000, 2001, 2002, we asked for 1,895 people
-- agents, linguists, analysts. We got a total of 76 people during
that period," Freeh said.
"That's not to criticise the U.S. Congress. It's not to criticise
the Department of Justice. It is to focus on the fact that that was
not a national priority."
Freeh, questioned by Democratic commissioner Richard Ben-Veniste,
later said intelligence services were aware of the danger that a
terrorist might use a hijacked plane as a weapon.
He acknowledged steps were taken to protect the White House as
well as special events, such as the 2000 Olympic Games and meetings
of world leaders, against such a threat, but nothing was done to
protect the country at large.
'WELL-KNOWN THREAT'
Ben-Veniste asked: "So it was well known in the intelligence
community that this was a potential threat?"
Freeh responded: "It was part of the planning for those events,
that is correct."
The commission was to hear later from Ashcroft, and his
Democratic predecessor, Janet Reno.
The staff report also focused on FBI failures to detect the 9/11
plot, amid new revelations contained in a presidential briefing that
the bureau had some 70 separate investigations related to Osama bin
Laden's al Qaeda network underway a month before the attacks.
The newly declassified August 6, 2001, briefing said the FBI had
detected suspicious activity "consistent with preparations for
hijackings or other types of attacks."
The report found the FBI was hampered by a culture resistant to
change, inadequate resources and legal barriers.
Despite significant resources devoted to investigations of major
terrorist attacks that resulted in several prosecutions, FBI
attempts to prevent such attacks failed to make changes across the
bureau, it said.
"On September 11, 2001, the FBI was limited in several areas
critical to an effective, preventive counterterrorism strategy," the
report said, citing limited intelligence collection and analysis
capabilities, limited information sharing, insufficient training, an
overly complex legal regime and inadequate resources.
Although the FBI's counterterrorism budget tripled during the
mid-1990s, its counterterrorism spending stayed fairly constant
between fiscal years 1998 and 2001, it added.
On September 11, 2001, only about 1,300 agents, or 6 percent of
the FBI's total personnel, worked on counterterrorism.
"Former FBI officials told us that prior to 9/11, there was not
sufficient national commitment or political will to dedicate the
necessary resources to counterterrorism," the report said.